Skip to content
AnsweredAAbutPierQ&A #1916302005-04-22 13:17 · Views 74

Difference between ASolver and SAP results

asolver와 sap 결과값 차이가 원래 나는지 궁금합니다. 답변 부탁드립니다.

Answer

안녕하세요. 한길아이티입니다. 어떤 해석 프로그램도 정해의 100%를 맞춰주지는 못합니다. 또한 동일한 구조물을 다른 해석 프로그램으로 해석하더라도 동일한 값은 나오지 않습니다. 보통 해석프로그램은 정해의 95% 정도가 되면 공학적으로 가치가 있는 결과라고 판단하고 여기에 맞춰 설계를 하게 됩니다. 따라서 해석 프로그램마다 조금씩의 차이는 있게 마련입니다. 감사합니다.

More in this list

StatusProductNo.TitleViewsDate
AnsweredAAbutPier#268560Question about the calculation report1812026-09-29
AnsweredAAbutPier#268548Tendon force when placing tendons in the pier cap2212026-09-29
AnsweredAAbutPier#268520Pier seismic check2572026-09-23
AnsweredAAbutPier#268509Transverse reinforcement factor, K2022026-09-22
AnsweredAAbutPier#268492Girder positions in slab dimensions3452026-09-21
AnsweredAAbutPier#268483Transverse pile member forces are "0" in pier pile foundation check2032026-09-21
AnsweredAAbutPier#268482Top and bottom rebar detailing error in pier foundation STM2242026-09-21
AnsweredAAbutPier#268476Question about slab dimensions3122026-09-19
AnsweredAAbutPier#268470Settlement and bearing capacity2742026-09-18
AnsweredAAbutPier#268462Superstructure wind load in the calculation report1932026-09-18
AnsweredAAbutPier#268451Changing bearing location882026-09-18
AnsweredAAbutPier#268445Main rebar placement2962026-09-17
AnsweredAAbutPier#268438Modeling error in seismic analysis4112026-09-17
AnsweredAAbutPier#268433Pier alignment center1892026-09-17
AnsweredAAbutPier#268431Please check the design ground surface displacement2372026-09-17
AnsweredAAbutPier#268422Question about pier2692026-09-17
AnsweredAAbutPier#268416Wprov calculation in the structural calculation report2562026-09-17
AnsweredAAbutPier#268402Increasing the number of column main rebars3982026-09-16
AnsweredAAbutPier#268392Question about cast-in-place piles2262026-09-16
AnsweredAAbutPier#268387Error when entering reinforcing rebar1802026-09-16
Sign in to ask