Skip to content
AnsweredAAbutPierQ&A #1267752014-05-27 19:32 · Views 743

Member force summary cases differ in P-Δ analysis

첨부한 계산서를 보면 기둥검토시 적용된 축력과 P-Δ모멘트의 하중조합케이스가 상이합니다 검토 부탁드립니다.

Answer

안녕하세요. 한길아이티입니다. 프로그램파일을 첨부해주셔야 정확한 답변을 드리는 것이 가능합니다. 수고스러우시겠지만 apr파일의 첨부를 부탁드립니다. 감사합니다.

Answer

안녕하세요. 한길아이티입니다. 일반적인 경우는 프레임해석과 P-delta해석의 축방향단면력이 동일하나 다주식 등에서 기둥별 축력의 결과가 상이한 경우가 확인되었습니다. P-delta해석으로 적용시에는 P-delta의 해당조합 축력으로 검토를 적용하도록 변경하였으며 패치후 설계검토 또는 계산서 출력시 확인가능합니다. 감사합니다.

Attached images

1 attached file · Only the person who posted and our support staff can open them.

Sign in if this is your post

More in this list

StatusProductNo.TitleViewsDate
AnsweredAAbutPier#195610Please check column shear design792005-10-26
AnsweredAAbutPier#195597Foundation shear reinforcement312005-10-26
AnsweredAAbutPier#195596Entering dimensions in pier section drawing372005-10-26
AnsweredAAbutPier#195593Horizontal force application seems wrong302005-10-26
AnsweredAAbutPier#195587Pier cap beam reinforcement detailing262005-10-26
AnsweredAAbutPier#195586Drawing output error292005-10-26
AnsweredAAbutPier#195578In bearing seat dimension input332005-10-26
AnsweredAAbutPier#195576Abutment reinforcement drawing402005-10-25
AnsweredAAbutPier#195573Pile layout when pier foundations are separated462005-10-25
AnsweredAAbutPier#195571*** used in pile calculation532005-10-25
AnsweredAAbutPier#195568Pile Excel output error632005-10-25
AnsweredAAbutPier#195560Please check432005-10-25
AnsweredAAbutPier#195550Error when generating drawings362005-10-24
AnsweredAAbutPier#195547Pile layout462005-10-24
AnsweredAAbutPier#195544Elevation error402005-10-24
AnsweredAAbutPier#195542[Earthwork quantity] Soft rock and weathered rock excavation quantities missing532005-10-24
AnsweredAAbutPier#195561Is allowable stress reduction for pile splices applied in design?562005-10-24
AnsweredAAbutPier#1955495) Concrete reinforcement at bridge bearings472005-10-24
AnsweredAAbutPier#195541Pier column check402005-10-24
AnsweredAAbutPier#195539Error in multi-column pier body and foundation152005-10-23
Sign in to ask